With prediction markets showing 87% odds that May inflation will exceed 2.3% and 35% probability it will top 2.4%, traders are betting that America's inflation fight is far from over. As Trump tariffs begin reshaping the economic landscape, consumers face a critical question: How much longer will elevated prices persist?
Sign up for Kalshi today to trade on inflation likelihood and other economic markets.
The stakes couldn't be higher. Every tenth of a percentage point in inflation translates to billions in additional costs for American families, affecting everything from grocery bills to mortgage rates. With current headline CPI at about 2.3% and core CPI at 2.8%, inflation remains stubbornly above the Federal Reserve's 2% target, and prediction markets suggest it could be headed higher.
Currently, inflation in the United States decreased to 2.3% in April from 2.4% in March of 2025, offering a reprieve after months of persistent price pressures. However, this apparent cooling may be temporary, as the full impact of President Donald Trump’s trade policies has yet to materialize.
How much longer can inflation last? The answer depends largely on tariff implementation and consumer response. Forecasting companies like Trading Economics anticipate inflation rates between 2.4% and 2.9% between the end of 2024 and the start of 2026, suggesting elevated inflation could persist well into next year.
The prediction markets reflect this uncertainty, with traders clearly expecting May's CPI reading to jump back above recent lows. At 87% probability for inflation exceeding 2.3%, the market is pricing in a reacceleration, showing a stark warning for consumers planning major purchases or financial decisions.
For everyday Americans, this means continued pressure on household budgets. Consumer prices climbed last month at the slowest pace since February 2021, as the inflationary effects of Trump's tariffs had yet to hit Americans' wallets. The key phrase: “Yet to hit.” The impact is coming.
The CPI for May 2025 will be released at 8:30 a.m. ET on Wednesday, June 11.
The May CPI prediction markets reveal sophisticated analysis of inflationary pressures through real money wagers. On Kalshi, traders buy shares for between 1-99 cents that pay $1 if their prediction proves correct, with current pricing reflecting collective wisdom about probability.
At 87 cents per share for "May inflation above 2.3%," traders risk losing most of their investment for only a 13-cent profit if correct, indicating high confidence this outcome will occur. Conversely, betting against this consensus at 13 cents per share offers an 87-cent profit if inflation goes below 2.3%, but traders lose everything if wrong.
What traders are pricing in:
• The average effective US tariff rate after incorporating all 2025 tariffs is now 22.5%, the highest since 1909.
• April's surprisingly low 2.3% reading may have created an artificially low comparison point.
• The Consumer Sentiment Index dropped to 50.8 this month, the lowest reading since June 2022
Unlike traditional economic forecasting, which offers vague probability ranges, Kalshi's markets demand binary clarity. Either May inflation exceeds these thresholds or it doesn't. This precision forces traders to grapple with exact definitional questions. Does core CPI matter more than headline? How do seasonal adjustments affect the calculation? These questions make prediction markets more sophisticated tools than simple polling about inflation “expectations.”
Housing costs continue driving inflation higher as rental prices remain elevated, affecting the largest component of CPI calculations.
Transportation expenses face ongoing volatility with gas prices trending higher due to geopolitical tensions, while food costs offer mixed signals, as prices for fresh vegetables are predicted to decrease by 2.9%in 2025, providing some relief for grocery budgets.
Consumers considering major purchases like appliances or electronics should buy before tariff costs fully hit retail prices. Those with variable-rate debt should evaluate fixed-rate refinancing options since Fed rate cuts appear potentially delayed. Most importantly, families need to adjust their budgets for 2.5-3% inflation through 2025 rather than assuming the Fed's 2% target will be achieved.
Trump's imposed and scheduled tariffs will increase federal tax revenues by $156.4 billion, or 0.51% of GDP, making the tariffs the largest tax hike since 1993. This massive fiscal impact will ripple through the economy, potentially keeping inflation elevated even as other pressures ease.
The inflation prediction markets offer sophisticated investors several ways to hedge against or profit from rising prices through various trading strategies.
Kalshi CPI markets present immediate opportunities, with the current 87% probability for May inflation exceeding 2.3% offering potential profits if you believe inflation will stay lower than consensus expects. Professional longer-term inflation swaps are pricing 2.7% average inflation through 2026, creating opportunities for those willing to bet against sustained price pressures.
Import-heavy retailers like Walmart and Target face significant margin pressure as tariff costs hit their supply chains, making them potential short candidates for sophisticated traders. Conversely, US manufacturers may benefit from reduced foreign competition, positioning domestic producers as potential winners in the new trade environment. Agricultural and energy commodities markets are already responding to trade disruptions, creating volatility that experienced traders can exploit.
Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) offer the most direct hedge against CPI increases, automatically adjusting principal values as inflation rises. Real estate historically provides strong inflation protection, though current rate sensitivity creates additional complexity for investors. Energy stocks often benefit from inflationary environments, particularly as input costs rise across the broader economy.
Remember that “consumers have spiraled from anxious to petrified,” according to economists, creating potential market volatility that can amplify both gains and losses. The key is positioning for sustained inflation above the Fed's 2% target while avoiding overexposure to any single bet or sector.
The prediction markets are sending a clear signal that inflation's next chapter is just beginning. With odds heavily favoring May CPI above the current 2.3%, smart money is betting that America's price pressures will intensify before they ease.
For consumers, the message is simple: Prepare for inflation to remain an unwelcome houseguest well into 2026.